norml23 - Page 47

Page 47 Previous , Next , Original Image
Return to Index

 1o DEA Failed to Follow the Dictates of the
 Court in NORML v. DEA
 The NORML v. DEA decision specifically ordered the DEA and HEW to
 separately consider four categories of marijuana materials, which the
 Court defined as follows: "Cannabis" and "cannabis resin;" cannabis
 leaves; cannabis seeds capable of germination; and synthetic THC.
 NORML v. DEA, supra, 559 F.Zd at 757. These four categories are
 discussed in detaim in the Court's decision, and were carefully defined
 by the Court. The "Conclusion" of the decision, which ordered the case
 remanded for further proceedings, specifically states that HEW is
 "directed to make separate evaluations and recommendations for each of
 the following cannabis materials.. "ld. at 757 (emphasis added)
 These categories are based upon the Single Convention, which requires
 substantially different levels of control for these different marijuana
 HEW's report did not, however, make separate findings and
 recommendations on the four categories of cannabis materials the NORML
 v. DEA Court ordered HEW to separately consider. Lnstead, HEW combined
 three of the four categories tog ether, and made a singte set of
 findings for these marijuana materials: "cannabis" and "cannabis
 resin," cannabis leaves and cannabis seeds capable of germination. See
 44 Fed. Reg. at 36125 Col. 3o HEW abo lumped together synthetic THC
 and extracted THC ("cannabis resin"), and made a single set of findings
 and recommendations for these two materiams, even though the NORML v.
 DEA Court specifically directed HEW to consider synthetic THC as a
 separate category. See 44 Fed. Reg. at 36126 Col. 2.
 DEA's finat decision also did not separately consider the four
 categories of cannabis materials the Court specified in its prior de-
 cision, but instead considered a confusing and overlapping variety of
 cannabis materials. In the "Summary" section at the beginning of the
 decision, and the "Conclusion" section at the end, only two categories
 are listed --"marijuana" and "synthetic THC." See, 44 Fed. Re9. at
 36123 Col. 1, 3612.5 CoL 1o In the "Findings" section, the DEA
 routinely combines synthetic and extracted THC together, 44 FedoReg. at
 36123 Col. 3, 36124 Col. !. In considering medical uses, the DEA
 refers in a unitary fashion to "marijuana, extracted and synthetic
 THC." 44 Fed. Reg. at 36124 CoL 2.
 The DEA abo failed to consider the fula range of scheduling

Previous , Next , Return to Index