norml21 - Page 54
Page 54
Previous ,
Next ,
Original Image
Return to Index
Although the fact situation in Mill's time (1850_s) was not
the same as the framers' time or the same as today_ his concepts
have retained their vitality:
(T)here is a sphere of action in which
society, as distinguished from the
individual, has, if any, only a_ indirect
interest; comprehending all that portion of a
person_s life and conduct which affects only
himself, or if it also affects others, only
with their freer voluntary_ and undeceived
consent and participation° When I say only
himself_ I mean directly, and if the first
instance; for whatever affects himself, may
affect others through himself .... this, then,
is the appropriate region of human liberty°
it comprises_ first the inward domain of
c onsciousAess; demanding liberty of
conscience in the most comprehensive sense;
liberty of thought and feeling; absolute
freedom of opinion and sentiment: on all
subjects, practical or speculative,
scientific, oralu or theological ....
Secondly_ the principle requires liberty of
tastes and pursuits; of framing the plan of
our life to suit our own character; of doing
as we like subject to such consequences as
may follow; without impediment from our
fellow creatures, so long as what we do does
not harm them, even though they should think
our conduct foolish_ perverse, cr wrong.
Thirdly, from this liberty of each
individual, follows th_ liberty, within the
same limits_ _f combin_ion amqn_
individuals; freedom to unite, for any
purpose not involving harm to others; the
persons combining being supposed to be of
full age, and not forced or deceived.
Hill, sup_r_a, at 15-16 (emphasis added)°
Mro Justice Brandeis, in a dissenting opinion which has
since risen above mundane legalisms and attained independent
54
Previous ,
Next ,
Return to Index